A little while ago, I sat in a Sunday school lesson that really got my blood pumping. I'm not one to rant about church principles or teachings but this one has kind of been eating at me ever since. I need to get it off my chest. So read at your own risk:
Money
"Christ was born into a poor family for a reason. Money corrupts people and causes people to be hard-hearted. Do you think Jesus Christ would have been able to do the things he did if he were born into a wealthy family? I think he would have had to learn to be humble and would have had to teach his mother and father to be humble. But since he was born into nothing, he was able to begin a humble ministry from the beginning." (and later) "I don't think we would have near as many problems in this world if everyone had only enough for their needs. We need to be honest with ourselves, decide what are necessities, and spend nothing more than what we need."
Oh boy. I have so many issues with this statement...
1. Having money does not mean that you are automatically corrupt. Such a statement is absurd. I'm pretty sure the prophet and his counselors (and most of our church leaders for that matter) are very wealthy. In fact, they are so wealthy, the majority of them can devote their lives to the Church and no longer work. I don't know many poor members who would be able to do that.
2. Christ was not chosen as the Son of God because he was born into a poor family. He, Mary, and Joseph were chosen because they were predestined for the great calling they were given. Yes, Christ was born into humble beginnings, but I do not believe for one second that he was successful simply because he happened to be poor, or that he would have been unsuccessful if he were born into wealth. In fact, I believe suggesting that the success of Christ’s ministry is contingent upon his environment is undermining his divine heritage and divine calling; he was the Son of God, no matter who his earthly parents might have been. And Mary and Joseph were chosen to be his earthly parents, not because of what was in their pockets, but because of what was in their hearts.
3. Money is not bad. If it were, the leaders of our church would give some instruction on this. Last time I checked, there was no official instruction from officials stating that we should only spend on our needs and never spend on wants. A good friend of mine ran into Thomas S. Monson (prophet and president of the LDS church) at a cabin along the Provo River. He was simply there on vacation. Vacation you say? How absurd! How dare this man spend money on such a frivolous thing? (Was my sarcasm evident enough?) I don't know about you, but I work hard for my money. And sometimes, I like to get a pedicure, or go out to dinner, or even go on vacation (gasp)! Necessity? To me, yes. It is a necessity to enjoy my life and do things that make me happy. Does it mean that I'm not living righteously? I'm going to go out on a limb and say "no."
Modesty
"The most important thing we can do as women (for the men) is to dress modestly. We are responsible for the way we are viewed by others. The men cannot help thinking bad thoughts when we are dressed immodestly. If you are noticing that you are attracting the wrong kind of guys, the first thing I would suggest you do is look at the way you are dressing. I can bet that that's the problem." (and later) "We have the responsibility to make these men see us for who we are:daughters of God. And to do that, we need to keep the distraction off of our physical appearance. I'm not saying makeup is bad, but there's no need to always wear it. And you don't need to always be 'dressed to the nines.' Doing that will only have the men attracted to us for the wrong reasons."
I'm not even sure where to start with this one...
1. Men are not mindless animals. They are able to think, act, and react just like women are. To state that it is the woman's responsibility to keep the man chaste is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard. And believe me, I hear a lot of wild things (I teach elementary school)! Can we, as women, assist in keeping their thoughts pure? Yes, absolutely. Are women at fault when a man thinks something inappropriate about them? Absolutely NOT!
What happened to agency? I'm pretty sure one of the most foundational and basic things we learn is that "men are free to choose according to their own will." Yes, modesty is important, if for no other reason than that the prophets have asked us (women and men) to be modest in our appearance. We live in a terrible world. We cannot hide our men (and our sons) from the things of the world. We as human beings are taught to "not judge a book by its cover" and "look inside one another" instead of at their appearance. Why is it then, that when it comes to women's modesty, that's not the case?
Additionally, to say that women are responsible for a man's thoughts by the way that they dress is to excuse men from any impure thoughts they may have. If your son is speaking crassly about immodestly dressed women, are you going to say, "It's ok for him to do that, because of the way she's dressed"? Take that one step farther, and the rapists who say "she was asking for it" by the way that their victims were dressed will get a pass too.
I believe women should dress modestly, not because it is our responsibility to keep the men around us chaste, but because it shows self-respect and is pleasing to our Father in Heaven.
2. Looking nice does not mean you are being immodest. Finding modest clothing is difficult, yes. But that does not mean that if it's cute, it's immodest. And just because something is modest, doesn’t automatically mean it is cute. (You all know someone who falls under this category.) Two weeks ago, I called the temple to book my sealing (hooray!) and was told that they will be closed for the majority of October for cleaning. I told the lady, "That's ok. We aren't getting married until December. If we are at the temple in October, it would only be outside for bridal photos." She informed me that the temple grounds will be getting a makeover as well. That all of the flowers will be replaced, the lawns fixed, and the exterior of the temple cleaned. If we are to believe that our bodies are temples, why is it then that we are not to keep up our own temples? If the temples are all kept beautiful inside and out, shouldn't we do the same? I think that taking care of our bodies and living the law of chastity is far more than simply eating right and refraining from alcohol and tobacco. I think we are also to do our best to keep up our physical appearance.
3. Our inner beauty is important, but so is our outer beauty. Now, before you turn into a lynch mob, let me say, inner beauty is more important than what's on the outside. Our outer appearance will fade (and all that other mushy-gushy stuff). Let me also say that beauty really is in the eye of the beholder. I am not suggesting that we all run out and have plastic surgery to look like the runway models or actresses on TV. However, we need to take care of our appearance! Trust me, I'm always dressed nice (those of you that know me are probably on the floor laughing right now). Welcome to real life. Nobody looks nice all the time (except maybe Kim Kardashian. But if I have to choose between that and looking like a train wreck, bring on the steam engine), but that does not mean we are exempt from putting forth effort because we want men to see us for our inner beauty.
It is much easier for men to see our inner beauty when they don't have to try to see past our frumpy clothing, oily faces, and dirty hair. We want men who are confident in themselves. Men want them same in women. And what better way to show them that we are confident in ourselves than to put forth a little bit of effort in our appearance? I know I'm a lot easier to love when I'm pretty. (Just ask Carlo.)
And that extends to loving ourselves as well. Think about the way you feel when you are clean, your hair is done, you have your makeup on, and you're wearing nice clothes. Compare that to how you feel when you haven't showered in two days, your hair's a mess, your face is oily, and you're in your old sweatpants. When do you feel more confident? More prone to love yourself? I believe our Heavenly Father wants us to feel good about ourselves, to be confident women who love ourselves and our bodies. And that is easier to do when you have put time and care into your appearance.
*Sigh* That was tiring. Now I feel better. I think what upsets me the most of all of this is that (1)not one person disagreed out loud (except me), and (2) this is not the first time I've heard similar comments made during church discussions.
Thoughts? Ideas? Hate mail? I'd love to hear it all. I'm off to go get pretty and spend some money.